Im just saying that this game needs to keep going with what they are doing. But i just got this game wednesday and its already the same thing for me The only replayable story to me is the taboo one. The Samantha rapeish story. Don't say its not rape cause if that happened in the real world it would be rape if he got caught. Yeah she wanted it but its still rape.

I think these kind of fetishes are best left to modding at first.
In a later stage when the game grows, these kind of relations could be added.
Just like GTA, when it contains lots of features, the extreme aspects are not so obvious anymore.

I do. However, I know it'd never be done. Not necessarily because it's taboo, but because it's a lot of work for something a non-vocal group would be interested in. And hey, if you want to kill the girl during intercourse, be my guest. It could happen the other way around in Rapelay. I see no problem with something like that being in the game.

I'm not pushing any particular story, though. What the game is now took the hard work of the few devs that exist. I'd rather they continue working on improving the gameplay rather than trying to come up with stories. Stories are best left to the users, if that becomes possible.

Notoriety and (not) going to extremes are good points. Leaning to far out the window includes the risk of falling and (metaphorically) breaking your neck.

I don't see this being a problem, reminds me of that hentai.. I think it was called Stepmother, a milf would totally be sexy.

Hopefully, nobody wants something like this to be an XSP-Story...

This argument seems odd when it's only applied to incest or underage sex. Yes you completely do rape Samantha when you give her sleeping pills and have sex with her, that's rape under any circumstances and unlike most kinds of rough sex, not that many people are turned on by sex while they're unconscious or fantasize about it. But it's probably many times more likely than seducing some lolita/step sister or whatever, statistically speaking. Anyway we're not talking about what's ok in society to do, we're talking about a video game simulation. Doesn't matter how 'realistic', it's not real and literally no one gets hurt any more than they do in CoD or GTA.

And if you want to talk about what's ok to have in a fantasy that's a slippery slope. Several countries have tried to ban cg 'virtual child pornography' with the same laws as actual children's images, as if it's more about getting rid of the sick pedophiles' fantasies than it is about protecting real children from sexual abuse. Sometimes they present the dubious theory that pedophiles will be more likely to rape children after seeing virtual child porn, which is not at all supported by research and doesn't make sense anyway. In fact there's evidence of the opposite effect, if potential rapists and abusers channel their urges into fantasy they're less likely to obsess over real victims. Japan certainly doesn't have the highest rape or child abuse stats, but few would argue they let real life taboos carry over into art and porn.

Personally I'm not any more concerned than I am about people playing XStoryPlayer and forgetting they shouldn't pull out their dick and pee on a girl in a gym shower or whatever. I say anything goes or the terrorists win.

I have no problem with a "No Holds Barred" attitude for mods but all you have to do to see why there should be some guidelines is look at what happened to Rapelay. Even though the player is killed in the end the mere fact thee game contained underaged rape resulted in the game being vilified and pulled from shelves. Personally I would love to see this game go as far as it can but if the core version contains "underage sex" the puritans and moralists will do their best to kill it. The fact that everyday REAL children are raped and abused sometimes by these same people is irrelevant to them. We may not like it but we have to live in a world populated by ignorant and judgemental people who are always looking for a target to attack and make them feel relevant and more "moral".

All porn games are looked down on, and Rapeplay didn't get that press until years after release. It just got the game more attention. Illusion games work much differently when it comes to distribution. XStoryPlayer is distributed digitally and thus easier for people to support the company. There's no shelf for this to get pulled from.


I'd like for it to push every boundary, but considering the size of the developing team, we have to move one step at a time. As much as I like what the game is now, it's still a very basic foundation for what it's to become.

Underage characters, incest, scat, murder, necrophilia, or whatever "extreme" you want added, it's still going to be missing what it needs at this moment.

In summation, I'm all for extreme additions. Any press is good press as long as X Moon doesn't get shut down. However, we've got a long way to go before they'd be worth adding.

That why it in "ADULT" mate, because of different people fetish and bloody stuff happening, that why there's porn games and adult rated games, it to live out their fantasy so that it won't reach the outside, if you can't even live out your fantasy in a porn game or adult game whatever works, then people might as well live it out side. Porn games or adult games is probably developed for such purpose, limiting it is like forcing someone to do something brutal in the outside (which many have failed in holding their lust in). A lot of new fetish are popping up in the revenue, no one can really say "TABOO" when the one hating it, dislike such fetish and other that agree with that person just follow along with the idea of hating such thing (like a innocent child born into a family of races and grow up to be one) if it not your fetish keep it to yourself other like to express their own, even if you don't. With becoming someone involved in "adult" section comes with responsibility, if you can't keep your lust in then you have failed that trial and will commit something horrid, that why it is labeled "ADULT" for those that has responsibility, although some adult really aren't but, if not than what the point of putting that word on it. I can't really make it into sense but I did the best I can to make it into sense. Oh forgot one more thing, I bet those definitely are thing you hate, that why it so specific, oh and don't get me wrong I do hate those too but only in (IRL) only but not in (Fantasy Life) and the one with kill the women I definitely dislike that one more than the loli, oh I only get arouse for the sex part only, still hate it though.